Opinion: When Usman Khawaja picked the scab off Australian cricket’s sandpaper-induced wound, I doubt even he could have imagined the bleeding that was to follow, writes TVNZ Sport Presenter Scotty Stevenson. That blood is on the governing body’s hands.
So here we are. Another day in the life of a true blue Ocker sporting scandal and another opportunity for Cricket Australia to prove that it, as an organisation, has no appetite for the truth. Yesterday, CEO Todd Greenberg and iconic former test player, match referee, and current Interim Chair of CA, David Boon, fronted the media to shut down any chance of a fresh investigation into the Australian test team’s use of sandpaper to tamper with the ball during the series against South Africa in 2018.
Instead, the organisation has opted to create an independent forum for players and associated parties on that tour to offer their version of events. Participation is not compulsory, and the Cricket Australia Board will decide what, if any, conclusions will be released to the public at the end of a process they hope to have wrapped up by Christmas. Ho ho ho.
Hours later, Cameron Bancroft, the test player captured on television cameras at the time using the most famous scrap of sandpaper in sports history to rough up the ball, and subsequently one of three players suspended following a rushed investigation (the others being Steve Smith and David Warner) broke his silence in a detailed articulation of his side of the story printed in The West Australian newspaper.
In a nutshell, he claims, they – the whole team, coaches and all – knew what was happening.
'True' blue Australians?

That’s what Usman Khawaja wrote in his biography, Sabr. That’s what David Warner backed up in his subsequent social media post defending Khawaja from the incoming backlash. That’s what Chadd Sayers, 12th man during that Cape Town test when the cameras caught out Cameron Bancroft, claimed was the truth. In between Usman Khawaja’s book release, and Cameron Bancroft’s tell all, Pat Cummins, the Australian test captain, fronted the media for more than an hour. He denied everything. As he did in 2021, alongside fellow bowlers Josh Hazelwood, Nathan Lyon, and Mitchell Stark.
Of all the asinine phrases thrust upon us by this attention-seeking, self-platforming, half-cocked, under nourished, social media society, "my truth" might be the very worst of them. Fortunately, neither Greenberg nor Boon can be accused of using that phrase. In fact, neither seemed familiar with the word "truth" or its definition while describing what the forum was attempting to uncover.
We did find out the players could “share their experiences and perspectives”, and “tell their stories”, and offer their “version of events”. And the "truth"? What of that seemingly foreign concept? Here’s Todd Greenberg introducing an all new prefix:
“Someone’s version of events will contradict someone else’s version of events so looking for the perfect truth [emphasis mine] doesn’t exist, and we’re not chasing that.”
Scuffing for answers

In fairness to Greenberg, he may not be aware of the Hindu concept of "perfect truth", which incidentally is described as the Supreme God, transcending ethics and materiality, comprehended by enlightened souls through deep philosophical exploration, and achievable through comprehensive understanding of all facets of existence.
So, here’s a question: if not the perfect truth, what kind of truth was Cricket Australia pursuing in 2018 when then Executive General Manager of Team Performance, Pat Howard, and Senior Legal Counsel and Head of Integrity, Iain Roy, conducted the initial review into this matter in the space of – wait for it – four days?
What kind of truth was this: Steve Smith, David Warner, and Cameron Bancroft are the three perpetrators, and they will take the rap accordingly while the rest of you guys go play the next test?
Given the events of the past 10 days, that feels a long way from the "perfect truth", or any kind of truth for that matter, including "the" truth.
Scratching away at 'a shallow grave'

Maybe there is no such thing as a perfect truth in the secular world of Australian cricket, but there is a balance of probabilities.
An investigation is supposed to weigh up evidence, form conclusions based upon that evidence, and leave no stone unturned in gathering the very evidence it needs to weigh up. Of all the revelations Khawaja made in his book, his claim he was not even questioned by the original investigators is nothing short of staggering. Here’s "a" truth: an investigation of that kind deserved to be undertaken with greater forensic endeavour across a far more appropriate time period.
Cricket Australia put expediency above responsibility, a game of cricket above its duty to cricket. This is why it finds itself here today. Not because Cam Bancroft scratched the side of a cricket ball, but because the organisation he represented failed in its duty to discover the truth behind that act, perfect or otherwise. Now eight years have passed. Eight years of silences, eight years of denials, eight years of some versions of events, and some sides of the story and all the kinds of truth except for the one that really matters.
As veteran Australian cricket journalist, Peter Lalor, pointed out in an interview with ABC News Breakfast, “it’s almost like we’re back in 2018. This was buried in a shallow grave and eight years later we’re starting to find out the truth, and it’s a lot worse than we thought.”
Eight years on, it's still not over

In 2018, a group of young men decided to do something they should not have done. A group of older men had the chance to find out exactly how that came to pass. They didn’t take it then. They still refuse to take it now. Cricket Australia had eight years to make this right and now they want a month longer, to keep being wrong.
That’s the truth. Or, at the very least, that’s one version of it.



















SHARE ME