Aged care workers and nurses say they have finally been heard after the High Court found the National-led coalition’s pay equity law changes - which scrapped 33 active claims - unjustifiably discriminate against women.
In a decision released today, Justice Paul Radich also found the main driver for the changes was about money, and that there was nothing tangible in official papers to support some arguments from ministers that the old system was broken.
The declaration does not cancel the law, which remains in force, but is a formal finding that the law breaches a protected right. The Crown can still appeal the decision.
The case was brought by five unions which represent health staff, teachers, public servants and tertiary education staff.
Govt's 'discriminatory' pay equity changes driven by money, High Court finds - Watch on TVNZ+
Justice Radich declared the amended Equal Pay Act inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, which protects people from sex-based discrimination. He said a declaration recognised the rights of women working in “undervalued female dominated workforces”.
"They have, for the reasons I have given, been the subject of unjustified discrimination on the basis of their sex. A declaration vindicates their positions. They deserve to have the importance of the right, and the fact of its breach, recognised by the court."
The Equal Pay Amendment Act passed under urgency in May 2025, with all three readings on one day and no select committee process.
It cancelled 33 pay equity claims and raised the threshold for a “female dominated” workforce from 60% to 70% for at least 10 consecutive years.
The changes also limited claimants to comparators within their own industry or sector.
Outgoing Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden said in a statement the decision was being “carefully considered” by officials.
"The Crown needs to consider whether to appeal, so that limits what I or any government minister can say. This Government committed to a well-functioning pay equity regime. We didn’t think the previous legislative regime got the settings right."
She added: "Given there is the possibility of appeal and government is operating in a caretaker capacity, I do not intend to comment further."
'Main driver was fiscal'
As set out in his decision, the judge appeared unpersuaded by the Crown's arguments that changes were meant to make pay equity “more robust, workable and sustainable”.
A group of organisations is asking the United Nations to investigate if the changes amount to systemic discrimination against women. (Source: Breakfast)
Lawyers for the Crown argued the changes were meant to secure the long-term sustainability of the pay equity system.
They said ministers wanted to keep pay equity but control the cost, which had previously been committed outside the yearly Budget process.
According to the Crown, ministers were concerned the old regime had low thresholds, little guidance and broadly scoped claims.
They also said pay reviews happened so often that it was hard to tell whether pay gaps came from sex-based discrimination or other factors.
But the judge examined official advice behind the decision and drew a different conclusion. Justice Radich said there was “nothing tangible” in the official papers to show the previous system wasn’t working as it should.
Pay equity and a BNZ buy-back are among the agenda. (Source: 1News)
“The documents, viewed as a whole, show that the main driver was fiscal,” he said.
"More proportionate changes could have been used to achieve a pay equity system that was more robust, workable and sustainable.
"The measures may achieve the Budget savings that the lead-in papers estimated, but they are not proportionate to the stated objectives."
He said the explanation that the old framework was unworkable only appeared after ministers had set a goal of passing the law before Budget 2025.
The unions lost two other arguments with the court finding the Government had not acted unlawfully by passing the law under urgency without consultation. It also found that cancelling claims did not breach the rights to natural justice.
Union calls on possible kingmaker to restore scheme
With the make-up of the next government still unknown, the Public Service Association (PSA) used the decision to call on parties to "take leadership" on the issue.
National secretary Fleur Fitzsimons called out possible kingmaker party Opportunity.
"The next Government whoever they are must reinstate the previous framework without delay and settle the 33 claims that were cancelled," she said.
Fears the government's pay equity reset will leave many community-funded services out of pocket. (Source: 1News)
"Every party negotiating to form a government should commit to it and we call on the Opportunity Party to take leadership on this if it is in a position to help form a government. No coalition deal should leave this egregious law on the books.
"Restoring pay equity is the right thing to do, and it's good for the economy."
Opportunity was opposed to the Government's 2025 overhaul of pay equity rules, but it was not part of the party's five so-called "bottom lines" expected to drive coalition talks.
Nurses Organisation delegate and aged care health care assistant Lisa Marriner said the ruling vindicated workers whose claim had been taken from them without notice.
More than 20 events were held across the country under the banner of the "Women's Day of Action for Pay Equity". (Source: 1News)
"Today we've been heard," she said.
“The court today said what we’ve known all along. What the Government did to us was wrong. They robbed low-paid women and their whānau so they could balance their books while caregivers are left struggling to pay their bills."
Once the declaration is final, the Attorney-General must notify Parliament, and the government of the day must present a formal response within six months.





















SHARE ME