Secret confessions to God seal fate of Australian killer daughter

7:27pm
Preparing an insulin injection.

An Adelaide woman captured in secret police recordings confessing to God that she had poisoned her parents has been found guilty of their murders.

Raelene Polymiadis, 66, will face two mandatory life sentences after jurors on Friday delivered unanimous verdicts in a South Australian Supreme Court trial that took more than five months.

She clutched the dock as the first verdict was read out, then dabbed at her eyes with a tissue after the second guilty verdict was announced, repeatedly shaking her head and blinking rapidly.

Polymiadis's bail was revoked and she was remanded in custody ahead of sentencing submissions over what minimum non-parole period Justice Sandi McDonald should set.

After a trial that began on June 15 and blew through its 12-week estimate due to illnesses and other delays, the jury needed less than five hours' deliberation.

They accepted Polymiaidis, who has type 1 diabetes, injected Brenda and Lynton Anderson with fatal doses of insulin in separate incidents in March 2022 and April 2023 respectively.

Both were aged 94 at the time of their deaths.

Each had faced declining health and both were strongly opposed to being moved into aged care.

'Thou shall not kill'

One potential motive raised by prosecutors was a misplaced idea that killing her parents would spare them from entering a nursing home.

After Brenda Anderson had a fall in February 2022, she was admitted to Noarlunga Hospital with a fractured vertebra, complicated by pneumonia and another fall.

She had been recovering and had a discharge plan, but after Polymiadis visited her mother on March 12, nursing staff found Brenda Anderson largely unresponsive.

The prosecution alleged Polymiadis twice administered insulin to her mother.

Lynton Anderson continued to live at home after his wife's death, but became more frail and his four children began staying there at night on a shift basis.

Two hours after Polymiadis left his home on April 30, 2023, a carer found Lynton Anderson unconscious.

He died on May 1 as a result of insulin toxicity, prompting Major Crime detectives to begin investigating both deaths.

On June 20 – the same day Polymiadis was interviewed by detectives for the first time – she bared her soul in a clear and unambiguous confession, prosecutor Michael Foundas told the jury.

"Please, Lord, you know, yes, I have sinned. I have. Thou shall not kill," Polymiadis said as Adele's Someone Like You played in her car.

"I have sinned twice in my life, and I hate it, but I also know ... your blessing, Lord, that they did not want to go to a nursing home, that was their wish."

A file image of a judge in a courtroom.

Polymiadias's brother, Graham Anderson, told the court he was the culprit who wanted his father to go into residential care, and they had argued about it just five days before his death.

Polymiadis later told Major Crime detectives that "if you want a cause of death for dad, try a broken heart".

"When your son tells you you're a burden, that you'll make it hard on your family, that you deserve to be in a nursing home," she sobbed during an interview with detectives.

'The perfect murder weapon'

Polymiadis's former boyfriend Ian Edward Willcourt had told the court she had told him that insulin was "the perfect murder weapon" because it was natural in the body and could not be detected.

Police also seized notes written by Polymiadis, including one which read: "What they will do is wait for a few weeks, months, year to see if I 'think I got away with it' and I get cocky and slip up."

"Hang on buddy, it could be a long ride, otherwise the suspect would be arrested now."

A handwritten note allegedly written by Raelene Polymiadis.

Polymiadis' husband, Michael, and her son, who had accompanied his mother to court throughout the trial, did not comment as they left the courthouse.

Justice McDonald thanked the jury for their service during the "long and difficult trial".

Polymiadis will reappear in court on December 16 for a directions hearing.

SHARE ME

More Stories