The risks that come as Chinese EVs shake up the NZ car market

A brand-new electric car for less than $30,000. Just a few years ago, it would have seemed unlikely. Now, New Zealand buyers have a growing choice of affordable EVs, with Chinese manufacturers leading the charge.

There are currently at least 13 options for fully electric cars available for under $40,000. Every one comes from a Chinese-owned manufacturer, even including the traditionally British brand MG.

Watch Gill Higgins' full report on TVNZ+

Two years ago, the cheapest regularly priced new EV was selling for just under $43,000. Now, the cheapest is the Dongfeng Box, priced at $29,990 plus on-road costs.

It's a five-seater with an advertised range of 317km, a 12-inch touchscreen, Apple CarPlay and a 360-degree camera. Features that would once have been reserved for much more expensive cars.

EV expert Gavin Shoebridge says Chinese manufacturers are routinely including what used to be "really high-end luxuries", effectively "democratising gadgets that used to cost thousands of dollars".

And he believes this is only the beginning.

Chinese EV manufacturers have benefited from lower labour costs, substantial state support and a vast domestic market, helping them build vehicles at prices many established carmakers struggle to match.

Intense competition

Now, with intense competition at home, they're increasingly looking overseas for growth - including to New Zealand. Shoebridge believes they're prepared to sacrifice short-term profits to establish themselves in foreign markets.

"China aren't scared of taking a hit in the short term in the foreign markets to win. And I expect China will win," he said.

For New Zealand consumers, he believes competition is good news. And it's not just the prices that are improving. While cheaper EVs generally have shorter ranges, every model currently listed for under $40,000 offers more than 200km on a charge, according to manufacturers' advertised figures.

The GWM Ora 5, for example, offers a claimed 435km of range for $36,990.

Gill Higgins checks out a Geely EX2, on sale for $32,990.

But Shoebridge says there are compromises and potential risks buyers should be aware of. For a start, not all the technological extras will appeal to everyone.

Some vehicles, including GWM Ora models, have driver-monitoring cameras designed to check whether motorists are paying attention to the road.

Shoebridge admits it's a feature he's not keen on. "Sometimes I tape over it."

The cameras also touch on a wider concern about the data modern cars collect - and who might be able to access it.

British newspaper The i Paper reported that some UK defence personnel had been instructed to park vehicles containing Chinese components at least two miles from a military intelligence facility because of security concerns. The report also raised concerns about vehicle sensors, satellite navigation systems and connections to drivers' mobile phones.

The collection of location information and other vehicle data isn't unique to Chinese manufacturers. But critics argue China's national security laws could allow authorities to demand access to information held by Chinese companies.

Chinese officials have dismissed allegations about security threats from Chinese-made vehicles as "groundless".

Unfamiliar manufacturer

For everyday New Zealand motorists, there are also more immediate questions about buying from an unfamiliar manufacturer. And there are lots of unfamiliar brands now. Dongfeng, Arcfox, GAC and BAIC are among the names many New Zealanders will be encountering for the first time.

Shoebridge says buyers should consider how well established a brand is locally, whether spare parts are readily available and how easily a vehicle can be serviced or repaired.

After all, car companies can and do disappear from markets. Even familiar names such as Saab and Holden have ceased production. For those wary of taking a risk, he recommends choosing an established brand with a strong warranty and reliable local support.

There's also another financial consideration: depreciation. Electric vehicles can lose value quickly, particularly when the price of new models keeps falling. Shoebridge acknowledges EVs can take a "bit of a hit" when it comes to resale value.

Charging costs can be a lot cheaper than petrol or diesel, but costs vary.

His solution? Buy second-hand. "Then all that depreciation's gone." A used vehicle may have already suffered much of its initial loss in value, although further depreciation is still possible.

Despite those concerns, Shoebridge believes the lower purchase prices and improving range will persuade more motorists to make the switch. And he says the savings don't stop when buyers leave the showroom.

Lower maintenance requirements

Electric vehicles generally have lower maintenance requirements than petrol cars, with no engine oil changes, cambelts or spark plugs to replace. They also avoid the cost of petrol, although electricity prices and charging habits make a big difference to the savings.

"Generally, the cost of running an electric car is the big selling point because to go 100 kms in an electric car is about $5. It's about $24 in a petrol car," Shoebridge says.

That comparison is for energy costs. EV owners also pay road-user charges of $76 per 1000km, adding $7.60 per 100km before transaction fees. Public fast charging can also be substantially more expensive than charging at home. Even so, for motorists able to charge cheaply at home, the overall savings can be significant.

The appeal of EVs is demonstrated by the fact more New Zealanders are already choosing vehicles that can be plugged in. In October, battery-electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles accounted for nearly 23% of new light-vehicle registrations.

China offers a glimpse of how much further the market could shift. There, battery-electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles accounted for more than two-thirds of new passenger-car retail sales in October.

New Zealand still has some way to go to match that figure. But with Chinese manufacturers competing fiercely on price, range and technology, Shoebridge believes change to the country's motoring landscape is already well underway.

Watch Gill Higgins' full report on TVNZ+

SHARE ME

More Stories